Skip to main content

Application Scenarios for the Quantum Internet
draft-irtf-qirg-quantum-internet-use-cases-19

Yes

Colin Perkins

No Objection

Mat Ford

Note: This ballot was opened for revision 18 and is now closed.

Ballot question: "Is this draft ready for publication in the IRTF stream?"

Brian Trammell
Yes
Comment (2023-10-13 for -18) Sent
Thank you for the well-written introduction to the application space for quantum computing. I feel vastly more informed about the expansion of quantum computing beyond QKD. I found the elaboration of the stages in section 5 especially useful.

One nit: though "privacy-preserving" and "blind" are in some contexts considered interchangeable, the acronym BQC is introduced in section 4.2 without expansion, which I found momentarily confusing. At least expand BQC on first use; perhaps consider using "Blind" in place of "privacy-preserving" in this section.
Colin Perkins
Yes
David Oran
Yes
Comment (2023-09-28 for -18) Not sent
Very well written and a great roadmap toward where the research is likely to go.
Mat Ford
No Objection