Pseudowire Redundancy on the Switching Provider Edge (S-PE)
draft-ietf-pals-redundancy-spe-03

Yes

(Deborah Brungard)

No Objection

(Alia Atlas)
(Alvaro Retana)
(Barry Leiba)
(Ben Campbell)
(Benoît Claise)
(Jari Arkko)
(Joel Jaeggli)
(Kathleen Moriarty)
(Martin Stiemerling)
(Spencer Dawkins)
(Stephen Farrell)
(Terry Manderson)

Note: This ballot was opened for revision 02 and is now closed.

Deborah Brungard Former IESG member
Yes
Yes (for -02) Unknown 

                            

                        
                    

                
            
        
            
                
                    

                        

                            Alia Atlas Former IESG member
                        

                        

                            
                            No Objection
                            
                        

                    

                    

                        

                            

                                No Objection 
                                
                                    (for -02)
                                
                                
                                    
                                    
                                         Unknown
                                    
                                
                            

                        

                        
                            

                                

                            

                        
                    

                
            
                
                    

                        

                            Alvaro Retana Former IESG member
                        

                        

                            
                            No Objection
                            
                        

                    

                    

                        

                            

                                No Objection 
                                
                                    (2015-10-19 for -02)
                                
                                
                                    
                                    
                                         Unknown
                                    
                                
                            

                        

                        
                            

                                
It is not clear that the solution applies to both static and dynamic MS-PWs.  The Introduction talks about reusing the signaling in RFC6870, but it is not until Section 3 when RFC6478 is mentioned that I realized the applicability.

                            

                        
                    

                
            
                
                    

                        

                            Barry Leiba Former IESG member
                        

                        

                            
                            No Objection
                            
                        

                    

                    

                        

                            

                                No Objection 
                                
                                    (2015-10-19 for -02)
                                
                                
                                    
                                    
                                         Unknown
                                    
                                
                            

                        

                        
                            

                                
Just total nit-level stuff here: unexpanded abbreviations that should be expanded.  

-- Abstract --
PE, T-PE
(Because the abstract has to stand alone.)

-- Section 2.1 --
CE

-- Section 3.1 --
AC

-- Section 4 --
CC, VCCV

                            

                        
                    

                
            
                
                    

                        

                            Ben Campbell Former IESG member
                        

                        

                            
                            No Objection
                            
                        

                    

                    

                        

                            

                                No Objection 
                                
                                    (2015-10-19 for -02)
                                
                                
                                    
                                    
                                         Unknown
                                    
                                
                            

                        

                        
                            

                                
Just some very minor nits:

- section 1, 2nd paragraph:

s/provide/providing

- section 3 and subsections:

Several occurrences of "Active Preferential Forwarding status bit" need a leading "the".

                            

                        
                    

                
            
                
                    

                        

                            Benoît Claise Former IESG member
                        

                        

                            
                            No Objection
                            
                        

                    

                    

                        

                            

                                No Objection 
                                
                                    (2015-10-19 for -02)
                                
                                
                                    
                                    
                                         Unknown
                                    
                                
                            

                        

                        
                            

                                
No objection regarding the publication of the document.
However, based on Linda Dunbar's OPS DIR review, and the Jimmy's answer, a new revision is needed with the agreed changed (see the OPS DIR list for the details)

                            

                        
                    

                
            
                
                    

                        

                            Jari Arkko Former IESG member
                        

                        

                            (was Discuss)
                            No Objection
                            
                        

                    

                    

                        

                            

                                No Objection 
                                
                                    (2015-10-22)
                                
                                
                                    
                                    
                                         Unknown
                                    
                                
                            

                        

                        
                            

                                
(I also agree with Robert that the document is fairly hard to read. This isn’t
the first document in the IETF to be like that, and I didn’t feel that this
issue is discuss-worthy.)

                            

                        
                    

                
            
                
                    

                        

                            Joel Jaeggli Former IESG member
                        

                        

                            
                            No Objection
                            
                        

                    

                    

                        

                            

                                No Objection 
                                
                                    (2015-10-21 for -02)
                                
                                
                                    
                                    
                                         Unknown
                                    
                                
                            

                        

                        
                            

                                
Linda Dunbar provided the opsdir review.

                            

                        
                    

                
            
                
                    

                        

                            Kathleen Moriarty Former IESG member
                        

                        

                            
                            No Objection
                            
                        

                    

                    

                        

                            

                                No Objection 
                                
                                    (for -02)
                                
                                
                                    
                                    
                                         Unknown
                                    
                                
                            

                        

                        
                            

                                

                            

                        
                    

                
            
                
                    

                        

                            Martin Stiemerling Former IESG member
                        

                        

                            
                            No Objection
                            
                        

                    

                    

                        

                            

                                No Objection 
                                
                                    (for -02)
                                
                                
                                    
                                    
                                         Unknown
                                    
                                
                            

                        

                        
                            

                                

                            

                        
                    

                
            
                
                    

                        

                            Spencer Dawkins Former IESG member
                        

                        

                            
                            No Objection
                            
                        

                    

                    

                        

                            

                                No Objection 
                                
                                    (for -02)
                                
                                
                                    
                                    
                                         Unknown
                                    
                                
                            

                        

                        
                            

                                

                            

                        
                    

                
            
                
                    

                        

                            Stephen Farrell Former IESG member
                        

                        

                            
                            No Objection
                            
                        

                    

                    

                        

                            

                                No Objection 
                                
                                    (for -02)
                                
                                
                                    
                                    
                                         Unknown
                                    
                                
                            

                        

                        
                            

                                

                            

                        
                    

                
            
                
                    

                        

                            Terry Manderson Former IESG member
                        

                        

                            
                            No Objection
                            
                        

                    

                    

                        

                            

                                No Objection 
                                
                                    (for -02)
                                
                                
                                    
                                    
                                         Unknown