Getting Rid of the Cruft: Report from an Experiment in Identifying and Reclassifying Obsolete Standards Documents
draft-ietf-newtrk-decruft-experiment-03
Technical Summary
This document seeks to deprecate a batch of Proposed Standards
that appear to be out of use. The IESG is asked to reclassify
them as Historic.
Working Group Summary
The WG developed the list of standards for deprecation in
a systematic way and has attempted to ensure that no standards
in current use are listed. There was no dissent during WG Last
Call. Several documents were removed from the list after IETF Last
Call as they were claimed to be still in use.
Protocol Quality
Reviewed by Brian Carpenter. All specifcations asserted still to
be in active use have been removed from the list.
Note to RFC Editor
The RFC Editor is requested to mark all the RFCs listed in
Section 3 (as amended below) as Historic and remove them from
the list of Proposed Standards.
Please correct the following typo in the second paragraph of
Section 1:
OLD:
Status) and RFC 3166 (Request to Move RFC 1433 to Historic Status).
NEW:
Status) and RFC 3166 (Request to Move RFC 1403 to Historic Status).
Please update the following paragraph in Section 3:
OLD:
During review RFCs 1518 and 1519 were removed, based on the fact that
work is ongoing to revise them. Similarly, RFCs 1381, 1382, 1471,
1472, 1473, 1582, and 1598 were removed based on the belief that they
were actively in use.
NEW:
During review RFCs 1518 and 1519 were removed, based on the fact that
work is ongoing to revise them. Similarly, RFCs 1381, 1382, 1471,
1472, 1473, 1582, 1598 and 1755 were removed based on the belief that
they were actively in use. RFC 1584 was removed based on an expected
future dependency.
Please DELETE the following two lines from Section 3:
RFC1584 (Multicast Extensions to OSPF)
RFC1755 (ATM Signaling Support for IP over ATM)