Constrained Resource Identifiers
draft-ietf-core-href-13
The information below is for an old version of the document.
| Document | Type |
This is an older version of an Internet-Draft whose latest revision state is "Active".
|
|
|---|---|---|---|
| Authors | Carsten Bormann , Henk Birkholz | ||
| Last updated | 2023-07-25 (Latest revision 2023-07-10) | ||
| Replaces | draft-hartke-t2trg-ciri | ||
| RFC stream | Internet Engineering Task Force (IETF) | ||
| Formats | |||
| Additional resources | Mailing list discussion | ||
| Stream | WG state | Waiting for WG Chair Go-Ahead | |
| Document shepherd | (None) | ||
| IESG | IESG state | I-D Exists | |
| Consensus boilerplate | Unknown | ||
| Telechat date | (None) | ||
| Responsible AD | (None) | ||
| Send notices to | (None) |
draft-ietf-core-href-13
CoRE Working Group C. Bormann, Ed.
Internet-Draft Universität Bremen TZI
Intended status: Standards Track H. Birkholz
Expires: 11 January 2024 Fraunhofer SIT
10 July 2023
Constrained Resource Identifiers
draft-ietf-core-href-13
Abstract
The Constrained Resource Identifier (CRI) is a complement to the
Uniform Resource Identifier (URI) that represents the URI components
in Concise Binary Object Representation (CBOR) instead of a sequence
of characters. This simplifies parsing, comparison and reference
resolution in environments with severe limitations on processing
power, code size, and memory size.
// (This "cref" paragraph will be removed by the RFC editor:) The
// present revision -13 of this draft picks up some additional
// discussion points and is intended as input to the CoRE WG meeting
// at IETF 117.
About This Document
This note is to be removed before publishing as an RFC.
Status information for this document may be found at
https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-ietf-core-href/.
Discussion of this document takes place on the Constrained RESTful
Environments Working Group mailing list (mailto:core@ietf.org), which
is archived at https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/core/.
Subscribe at https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/core/.
Source for this draft and an issue tracker can be found at
https://github.com/core-wg/href.
Status of This Memo
This Internet-Draft is submitted in full conformance with the
provisions of BCP 78 and BCP 79.
Bormann & Birkholz Expires 11 January 2024 [Page 1]
Internet-Draft Constrained Resource Identifiers July 2023
Internet-Drafts are working documents of the Internet Engineering
Task Force (IETF). Note that other groups may also distribute
working documents as Internet-Drafts. The list of current Internet-
Drafts is at https://datatracker.ietf.org/drafts/current/.
Internet-Drafts are draft documents valid for a maximum of six months
and may be updated, replaced, or obsoleted by other documents at any
time. It is inappropriate to use Internet-Drafts as reference
material or to cite them other than as "work in progress."
This Internet-Draft will expire on 11 January 2024.
Copyright Notice
Copyright (c) 2023 IETF Trust and the persons identified as the
document authors. All rights reserved.
This document is subject to BCP 78 and the IETF Trust's Legal
Provisions Relating to IETF Documents (https://trustee.ietf.org/
license-info) in effect on the date of publication of this document.
Please review these documents carefully, as they describe your rights
and restrictions with respect to this document. Code Components
extracted from this document must include Revised BSD License text as
described in Section 4.e of the Trust Legal Provisions and are
provided without warranty as described in the Revised BSD License.
Table of Contents
1. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3
1.1. Notational Conventions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4
2. Constraints . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4
2.1. Constraints not expressed by the data model . . . . . . . 7
3. Creation and Normalization . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8
4. Comparison . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8
5. CRI References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9
5.1. CBOR Representation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10
5.1.1. The discard Section . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12
5.1.2. Visualization . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13
5.1.3. Examples . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13
5.1.4. Specific Terminology . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14
5.2. Ingesting and encoding a CRI Reference . . . . . . . . . 14
5.2.1. Error handling and extensibility . . . . . . . . . . 15
5.3. Reference Resolution . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16
6. Relationship between CRIs, URIs and IRIs . . . . . . . . . . 17
6.1. Converting CRIs to URIs . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17
7. Extending CRIs . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20
7.1. Extended CRI: Accommodating Percent Encoding (PET) . . . 21
8. Implementation Status . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 22
Bormann & Birkholz Expires 11 January 2024 [Page 2]
Internet-Draft Constrained Resource Identifiers July 2023
9. Security Considerations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23
10. IANA Considerations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23
10.1. CRI Scheme Numbers Registry . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23
10.1.1. Instructions for the Designated Expert . . . . . . . 23
10.1.2. Structure of Entries . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24
10.1.3. Initial Registrations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24
10.2. Update to "Uniform Resource Identifier (URI) Schemes"
Registry . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24
11. References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24
11.1. Normative References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24
11.2. Informative References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 26
Appendix A. Mapping Scheme Numbers to Scheme Names . . . . . . . 27
Appendix B. The Small Print . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 43
Appendix C. Change Log . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 44
Acknowledgements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 47
Contributors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 47
Authors' Addresses . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 47
1. Introduction
The Uniform Resource Identifier (URI) [RFC3986] and its most common
usage, the URI reference, are the Internet standard for linking to
resources in hypertext formats such as HTML [W3C.REC-html52-20171214]
or the HTTP "Link" header field [RFC8288].
A URI reference is a sequence of characters chosen from the
repertoire of US-ASCII characters. The individual components of a
URI reference are delimited by a number of reserved characters, which
necessitates the use of a character escape mechanism called "percent-
encoding" when these reserved characters are used in a non-delimiting
function. The resolution of URI references involves parsing a
character sequence into its components, combining those components
with the components of a base URI, merging path components, removing
dot-segments, and recomposing the result back into a character
sequence.
Overall, the proper handling of URI references is quite intricate.
This can be a problem especially in constrained environments
[RFC7228], where nodes often have severe code size and memory size
limitations. As a result, many implementations in such environments
support only an ad-hoc, informally-specified, bug-ridden, non-
interoperable subset of half of RFC 3986.
Bormann & Birkholz Expires 11 January 2024 [Page 3]
Internet-Draft Constrained Resource Identifiers July 2023
This document defines the _Constrained Resource Identifier (CRI)_ by
constraining URIs to a simplified subset and representing their
components in Concise Binary Object Representation (CBOR) [RFC8949]
instead of a sequence of characters. This allows typical operations
on URI references such as parsing, comparison and reference
resolution (including all corner cases) to be implemented in a
comparatively small amount of code.
As a result of simplification, however, CRIs are not capable of
expressing all URIs permitted by the generic syntax of RFC 3986
(hence the "constrained" in "Constrained Resource Identifier"). The
supported subset includes all URIs of the Constrained Application
Protocol (CoAP) [RFC7252], most URIs of the Hypertext Transfer
Protocol (HTTP) [RFC9110], Uniform Resource Names (URNs) [RFC8141],
and other similar URIs. The exact constraints are defined in
Section 2.
1.1. Notational Conventions
The key words "MUST", "MUST NOT", "REQUIRED", "SHALL", "SHALL NOT",
"SHOULD", "SHOULD NOT", "RECOMMENDED", "NOT RECOMMENDED", "MAY", and
"OPTIONAL" in this document are to be interpreted as described in
BCP 14 [RFC2119] [RFC8174] when, and only when, they appear in all
capitals, as shown here.
In this specification, the term "byte" is used in its now customary
sense as a synonym for "octet".
Terms defined in this document appear in _cursive_ where they are
introduced (rendered in plain text as the new term surrounded by
underscores).
2. Constraints
A Constrained Resource Identifier consists of the same five
components as a URI: scheme, authority, path, query, and fragment.
The components are subject to the following constraints:
C1. The scheme name can be any Unicode string (see Definition D80
in [Unicode]) that matches the syntax of a URI scheme (see
Section 3.1 of [RFC3986], which constrains schemes to ASCII)
and is lowercase (see Definition D139 in [Unicode]). The
scheme is always present.
C2. An authority is always a host identified by an IP address or
registered name, along with optional port information, and
optionally preceded by user information.
Bormann & Birkholz Expires 11 January 2024 [Page 4]
Internet-Draft Constrained Resource Identifiers July 2023
Alternatively, the authority can be absent; the two cases for
this defined in Section 3.3 of [RFC3986] are modeled by two
different values used in place of an absent authority:
* the path can be root-based (zero or more path components
that are each started in the URI with "/", as when the
authority is present), or
* the path can be rootless, which requires at least one path
component.
(Note that in Figure 1, no-authority is marked as a feature, as
not all CRI implementations will support authority-less URIs.)
C3. A userinfo is a text string built out of unreserved characters
(Section 2.3 of [RFC3986]) or "sub-delims" (Section 2.2 of
[RFC3986]); any other character needs to be percent-encoded
(Section 7.1). Note that this excludes the ":" character,
which is commonly deprecated as a way to delimit a cleartext
password in a userinfo.
C4. An IP address can be either an IPv4 address or an IPv6 address,
optionally with a zone identifier [RFC6874]. Future versions
of IP are not supported (it is likely that a binary mapping
would be strongly desirable, and that cannot be designed ahead
of time, so these versions need to be added as a future
extension if needed).
C5. A registered name is a sequence of one or more _labels_, which,
when joined with dots (".") in between them, result in a
Unicode string that is lowercase and in Unicode Normalization
Form C (NFC) (see Definition D120 in [Unicode]). (The syntax
may be further restricted by the scheme. As per Section 3.2.2
of [RFC3986], a registered name can be empty, for which case a
scheme can define a default for the host.)
C6. A port is always an integer in the range from 0 to 65535.
Ports outside this range, empty ports (port subcomponents with
no digits, see Section 3.2.3 of [RFC3986]), or ports with
redundant leading zeros, are not supported.
C7. The port is omitted if and only if the port would be the same
as the scheme's default port (provided the scheme is defining
such a default port) or the scheme is not using ports.
C8. A path consists of zero or more path segments. Note that a
path of just a single zero-length path segment is allowed —
this is considered equivalent to a path of zero path segments
Bormann & Birkholz Expires 11 January 2024 [Page 5]
Internet-Draft Constrained Resource Identifiers July 2023
by HTTP and CoAP, but this equivalence does not hold for CRIs
in general as they only perform normalization on the Syntax-
Based Normalization level (Section 6.2.2 of [RFC3986], not on
the scheme-specific Scheme-Based Normalization level
(Section 6.2.3 of [RFC3986]).
(A CRI implementation may want to offer scheme-cognizant
interfaces, performing this scheme-specific normalization for
schemes it knows. The interface could assert which schemes the
implementation knows and provide pre-normalized CRIs. This can
also relieve the application from removing a lone zero-length
path segment before putting path segments into CoAP Options,
i.e., from performing the check and jump in item 8 of
Section 6.4 of [RFC7252]. See also SP1 in Appendix B.)
C9. A path segment can be any Unicode string that is in NFC, with
the exception of the special "." and ".." complete path
segments. Note that this includes the zero-length string.
If no authority is present in a CRI, the leading path segment
cannot be empty. (See also SP1 in Appendix B.)
C10. A query always consists of one or more query parameters. A
query parameter can be any Unicode string that is in NFC. It
is often in the form of a "key=value" pair. When converting a
CRI to a URI, query parameters are separated by an ampersand
("&") character. (This matches the structure and encoding of
the target URI in CoAP requests.) Queries are optional; there
is a difference between an absent query and a single query
parameter that is the empty string.
C11. A fragment identifier can be any Unicode string that is in NFC.
Fragment identifiers are optional; there is a difference
between an absent fragment identifier and a fragment identifier
that is the empty string.
C12. The syntax of registered names, path segments, query
parameters, and fragment identifiers may be further restricted
and sub-structured by the scheme. There is no support,
however, for escaping sub-delimiters that are not intended to
be used in a delimiting function.
C13. When converting a CRI to a URI, any character that is outside
the allowed character range or is a delimiter in the URI syntax
is percent-encoded. For CRIs, percent-encoding always uses the
UTF-8 encoding form (see Definition D92 in [Unicode]) to
convert the character to a sequence of bytes (that is then
converted to a sequence of %HH triplets).
Bormann & Birkholz Expires 11 January 2024 [Page 6]
Internet-Draft Constrained Resource Identifiers July 2023
Examples for URIs at or beyond the boundaries of these constraints
are in SP2 in Appendix B.
2.1. Constraints not expressed by the data model
There are syntactically valid CRIs and CRI references that cannot be
converted into a URI or URI reference, respectively.
For CRI references, this is acceptable -- they can be resolved still
and result in a valid CRI that can be converted back. Examples of
this are:
* [0, ["p"]]: appends a slash and the path segment "p" to its base
(and unsets the query and the fragment)
* [0, null, []]: leaves the path alone but unsets the query and the
fragment
(Full) CRIs that do not correspond to a valid URI are not valid on
their own, and cannot be used. Normatively they are characterized by
the Section 6.1 process producing a valid and syntax-normalized URI.
For easier understanding, they are listed here:
* CRIs (and CRI references) containing a path component "." or "..".
These would be removed by the remove_dot_segments algorithm of
[RFC3986], and thus never produce a normalized URI after
resolution.
(In CRI references, the discard value is used to afford segment
removal, and with "." being an unreserved character, expressing
them as "%2e" and "%2e%2e" is not even viable, let alone
practical).
* CRIs without authority whose path starts with two or more empty
segments.
When converted to URIs, these would violate the requirement that
in absence of an authority, a URI's path cannot begin with two
slash characters, and they would be indistinguishable from a URI
with a shorter path and a present but empty authority component.
* CRIs without authority that are rootless and do not have a path
component (e.g., ["a", true]), which would be indistinguishable
from its root-based equivalent (["a"]) as both would have the URI
a:.
Bormann & Birkholz Expires 11 January 2024 [Page 7]
Internet-Draft Constrained Resource Identifiers July 2023
3. Creation and Normalization
In general, resource identifiers are created on the initial creation
of a resource with a certain resource identifier, or the initial
exposition of a resource under a particular resource identifier.
A Constrained Resource Identifier SHOULD be created by the naming
authority that governs the namespace of the resource identifier (see
also [RFC8820]). For example, for the resources of an HTTP origin
server, that server is responsible for creating the CRIs for those
resources.
The naming authority MUST ensure that any CRI created satisfies the
constraints defined in Section 2. The creation of a CRI fails if the
CRI cannot be validated to satisfy all of the constraints.
If a naming authority creates a CRI from user input, it MAY apply the
following (and only the following) normalizations to get the CRI more
likely to validate:
* map the scheme name to lowercase (C1);
* map the registered name to NFC (C5) and split it on embedded dots;
* elide the port if it is the default port for the scheme (C7);
* map path segments, query parameters and the fragment identifier to
NFC form (C9, C10, C11).
Once a CRI has been created, it can be used and transferred without
further normalization. All operations that operate on a CRI SHOULD
rely on the assumption that the CRI is appropriately pre-normalized.
(This does not contradict the requirement that when CRIs are
transferred, recipients must operate on as-good-as untrusted input
and fail gracefully in the face of malicious inputs.)
4. Comparison
One of the most common operations on CRIs is comparison: determining
whether two CRIs are equivalent, without dereferencing the CRIs
(using them to access their respective resource(s)).
Determination of equivalence or difference of CRIs is based on simple
component-wise comparison. If two CRIs are identical component-by-
component (using code-point-by-code-point comparison for components
that are Unicode strings) then it is safe to conclude that they are
equivalent.
Bormann & Birkholz Expires 11 January 2024 [Page 8]
Internet-Draft Constrained Resource Identifiers July 2023
This comparison mechanism is designed to minimize false negatives
while strictly avoiding false positives. The constraints defined in
Section 2 imply the most common forms of syntax- and scheme-based
normalizations in URIs, but do not comprise protocol-based
normalizations that require accessing the resources or detailed
knowledge of the scheme's dereference algorithm. False negatives can
be caused, for example, by CRIs that are not appropriately pre-
normalized and by resource aliases.
When CRIs are compared to select (or avoid) a network action, such as
retrieval of a representation, fragment components (if any) should be
excluded from the comparison.
5. CRI References
The most common usage of a Constrained Resource Identifier is to
embed it in resource representations, e.g., to express a hyperlink
between the represented resource and the resource identified by the
CRI.
This section defines the representation of CRIs in Concise Binary
Object Representation (CBOR) [RFC8949]. When reduced representation
size is desired, CRIs are not represented directly. Instead, CRIs
are indirectly referenced through _CRI references_. These take
advantage of hierarchical locality and provide a very compact
encoding. The CBOR representation of CRI references is specified in
Section 5.1.
The only operation defined on a CRI reference is _reference
resolution_: the act of transforming a CRI reference into a CRI. An
application MUST implement this operation by applying the algorithm
specified in Section 5.3 (or any algorithm that is functionally
equivalent to it).
The reverse operation of transforming a CRI into a CRI reference is
not specified in detail in this document; implementations are free to
use any algorithm as long as reference resolution of the resulting
CRI reference yields the original CRI. Notably, a CRI reference is
not required to satisfy all of the constraints of a CRI; the only
requirement on a CRI reference is that reference resolution MUST
yield the original CRI.
When testing for equivalence or difference, applications SHOULD NOT
directly compare CRI references; the references should be resolved to
their respective CRI before comparison.
Bormann & Birkholz Expires 11 January 2024 [Page 9]
Internet-Draft Constrained Resource Identifiers July 2023
5.1. CBOR Representation
A CRI or CRI reference is encoded as a CBOR array [RFC8949], with the
structure as described in the Concise Data Definition Language (CDDL)
[RFC8610] including its control extensions [RFC9165] as follows:
// RFC Ed.: throughout this section, please replace RFC-XXXX with the
// RFC number of this specification and remove this note.
Bormann & Birkholz Expires 11 January 2024 [Page 10]
Internet-Draft Constrained Resource Identifiers July 2023
; not expressed in this CDDL spec: trailing nulls to be left off
RFC-XXXX-Definitions = [CRI, CRI-Reference]
CRI = [
scheme,
authority / no-authority,
path / null,
query / null,
fragment / null
]
CRI-Reference = [
((scheme / null, authority / no-authority)
// discard), ; relative reference
path / null,
query / [] / null, ; [] is explicit unset
fragment / null
]
scheme = scheme-name / scheme-id
scheme-name = text .regexp "[a-z][a-z0-9+.-]*"
scheme-id = nint
no-authority = NOAUTH-ROOTBASED / NOAUTH-ROOTLESS
NOAUTH-ROOTBASED = null .feature "no-authority"
NOAUTH-ROOTLESS = true .feature "no-authority"
authority = [?userinfo, host, ?port]
userinfo = (false, text .feature "userinfo")
host = (host-ip // host-name)
host-name = (*text) ; lowercase, NFC labels
host-ip = (bytes .size 4 //
(bytes .size 16, ?zone-id))
zone-id = text
port = 0..65535
discard = DISCARD-ALL / 0..127
DISCARD-ALL = true
path = [*text]
query = [+text]
fragment = text
Figure 1: CDDL for CRI CBOR representation
Bormann & Birkholz Expires 11 January 2024 [Page 11]
Internet-Draft Constrained Resource Identifiers July 2023
The rules scheme, authority, path, query, fragment correspond to the
(sub-)components of a CRI, as described in Section 2, with the
addition of the discard section.
This CDDL specification is simplified for exposition and needs to be
augmented by the following rules for interchange of CRIs and CRI
references:
* Trailing null values MUST be removed,
* two leading null values (scheme and authority both not given) MUST
be represented by using the discard alternative instead, and
* an empty path in a CRI MUST be represented as the empty array []
(note that for CRI-Reference there is a difference between empty
and absent paths, represented by [] and null, respectively),
* an entirely empty outer array is not a valid CRI reference.
For interchange as separate encoded data items, CRIs MUST NOT use
indefinite length encoding (see Section 3.2 of [RFC8949]); this
requirement is relaxed for specifications that embed CRIs into an
encompassing CBOR representation that does provide for indefinite
length encoding.
5.1.1. The discard Section
The discard section can be used in a CRI reference when neither a
scheme nor an authority is present. It then expresses the operations
performed on a base CRI by CRI references that are equivalent to URI
references with relative paths and path prefixes such as "/", "./",
"../", "../../", etc. "." and ".." are not available in CRIs and are
therefore expressed using discard after a normalization step, as is
the presence or absence of a leading "/".
E.g., a simple URI reference "foo" specifies to remove one leading
segment from the base URI's path, which is represented in the
equivalent CRI reference discard section as the value 1; similarly
"../foo" removes two leading segments, represented as 2; and "/foo"
removes all segments, represented in the discard section as the value
true. The exact semantics of the section values are defined by
Section 5.3.
Bormann & Birkholz Expires 11 January 2024 [Page 12]
Internet-Draft Constrained Resource Identifiers July 2023
Most URI references that Section 4.2 of [RFC3986] calls "relative
references" (i.e., references that need to undergo a resolution
process to obtain a URI) correspond to the CRI form that starts with
discard. The exception are relative references with an authority
(called a "network-path reference" in Section 4.2 of [RFC3986]),
which discard the entire path of the base CRI. These CRI references
never carry a discard section: the value of discard defaults to true.
5.1.2. Visualization
The structure of a CRI reference is visualized using the somewhat
limited means of a railroad diagram:
cri-reference:
│├──╮── scheme ── authority ──╭── local-part ──┤│
│ │
╰──────── discard ────────╯
local-part:
╭─────────────────────>─────────────────────╮
│ │
│ ╭──────────────>──────────────╮ │
│ │ │ │
│ │ ╭──────>───────╮ │ │
│ │ │ │ │ │
│├──╯── path ──╯── query ──╯── fragment ──╰──╰──╰──┤│
This visualization does not go into the details of the elements.
5.1.3. Examples
[-1, / scheme -- equivalent to "coap" /
[h'C6336401', / host /
61616], / port /
[".well-known", / path /
"core"]
]
[true, / discard /
[".well-known", / path /
"core"],
["rt=temperature-c"]] / query /
[-6, / scheme -- equivalent to "did" /
true, / authority = NOAUTH-NOSLASH /
["web:alice:bob"] / path /
]
Bormann & Birkholz Expires 11 January 2024 [Page 13]
Internet-Draft Constrained Resource Identifiers July 2023
5.1.4. Specific Terminology
A CRI reference is considered _well-formed_ if it matches the
structure as expressed in Figure 1 in CDDL, with the additional
requirement that trailing null values are removed from the array.
A CRI reference is considered _absolute_ if it is well-formed and the
sequence of sections starts with a non-null scheme.
A CRI reference is considered _relative_ if it is well-formed and the
sequence of sections is empty or starts with a section other than
those that would constitute a scheme.
5.2. Ingesting and encoding a CRI Reference
From an abstract point of view, a CRI Reference is a data structure
with six sections:
scheme, authority, discard, path, query, fragment
Each of these sections can be unset ("null"), except for discard,
which is always an unsigned number or true. If scheme and/or
authority are non-null, discard must be true.
When ingesting a CRI Reference that is in the transfer form, those
sections are filled in from the transfer form (unset sections are
filled with null), and the following steps are performed:
* If the array is entirely empty, replace it with [0].
* If discard is present in the transfer form (i.e., the outer array
starts with true or an unsigned number), set scheme and authority
to null.
* If scheme and/or authority are present in the transfer form (i.e.,
the outer array starts with null, a text string, or a negative
integer), set discard to true.
Upon encoding the abstract form into the transfer form, the inverse
processing is performed: If scheme and/or authority are not null, the
discard value is not transferred (it must be true in this case). If
they are both null, they are both left out and only discard is
transferred. Trailing null values are removed from the array. As a
special case, an empty array is sent in place for a remaining [0]
(URI "").
Bormann & Birkholz Expires 11 January 2024 [Page 14]
Internet-Draft Constrained Resource Identifiers July 2023
5.2.1. Error handling and extensibility
It is recommended that specifications that describe the use of CRIs
in CBOR-based protocols use the error handling mechanisms outlined in
this section. Implementations of this document MUST adhere to rules
unless the containing document overrides them.
When encountering a CRI that is well-formed in terms of CBOR, but
that
* is not well-formed as a CRI,
* does not meet the other requirements on CRIs that are not covered
by the term "well-formed", or
* uses features not supported by the implementation,
the CRI is treated as "unprocessable".
When encountering an unprocessable CRI, the processor skips the
entire CRI top-level array, including any CBOR items contained in
there, and continues processing the CBOR items surrounding the
unprocessable CRI. (Note: this skipping can be implemented in
bounded memory for CRIs that do not use indefinite length encoding,
as mandated in Section 5.1.)
The unprocessable CRI is treated as an opaque identifier that is
distinct from all processable CRIs, and distinct from all
unprocessable CRIs with different CBOR representations. It is up to
implementation whether unprocessable CRIs with identical
representations are treated as identical to each other or not.
Unprocessable CRIs can not be dereferenced, and it is an error to
query any of their components.
This mechanism ensures that CRI extensions (using originally defined
features or later extensions) can be used without extending the
compatibility hazard to the containing document. For example, if a
collection of possible interaction targets contains several CRIs,
some of which use the "no-authority" feature, an application
consuming that collection that does not support that feature can
still offer the supported interaction targets.
Bormann & Birkholz Expires 11 January 2024 [Page 15]
Internet-Draft Constrained Resource Identifiers July 2023
The duty of checking validity is with the recipients that rely on
this validity. An intermediary that does not use the detailed
information in a CRI (or merely performs reference resolution) MAY
pass on a CRI/CRI reference without having fully checked it, relying
on the producer having generated a valid CRI/CRI reference. This is
true for both basic CRIs (e.g., checking for valid UTF-8) and for
extensions (e.g., checking both for valid UTF-8 and the minimal use
of PET elements in extended-cris as per Section 7.1).
5.3. Reference Resolution
The term "relative" implies that a "base CRI" exists against which
the relative reference is applied. Aside from fragment-only
references, relative references are only usable when a base CRI is
known.
The following steps define the process of resolving any well-formed
CRI reference against a base CRI so that the result is a CRI in the
form of an absolute CRI reference:
1. Establish the base CRI of the CRI reference and express it in the
form of an abstract absolute CRI reference.
2. Initialize a buffer with the sections from the base CRI.
3. If the value of discard is true in the CRI reference (which is
implicitly the case when scheme and/or authority are present in
the reference), replace the path in the buffer with the empty
array, unset query and fragment, and set a true authority to
null. If the value of discard is an unsigned number, remove as
many elements from the end of the path array; if it is non-zero,
unset query and fragment.
Set discard to true in the buffer.
4. If the path section is set in the CRI reference, append all
elements from the path array to the array in the path section in
the buffer; unset query and fragment.
5. Apart from the path and discard, copy all non-null sections from
the CRI reference to the buffer in sequence; unset query in the
buffer if query is the empty array [] in the CRI reference; unset
fragment in the buffer if query is non-null in the CRI reference.
6. Return the sections in the buffer as the resolved CRI.
Bormann & Birkholz Expires 11 January 2024 [Page 16]
Internet-Draft Constrained Resource Identifiers July 2023
6. Relationship between CRIs, URIs and IRIs
CRIs are meant to replace both Uniform Resource Identifiers (URIs)
[RFC3986] and Internationalized Resource Identifiers (IRIs) [RFC3987]
in constrained environments [RFC7228]. Applications in these
environments may never need to use URIs and IRIs directly, especially
when the resource identifier is used simply for identification
purposes or when the CRI can be directly converted into a CoAP
request.
However, it may be necessary in other environments to determine the
associated URI or IRI of a CRI, and vice versa. Applications can
perform these conversions as follows:
CRI to URI
A CRI is converted to a URI as specified in Section 6.1.
URI to CRI
The method of converting a URI to a CRI is unspecified;
implementations are free to use any algorithm as long as
converting the resulting CRI back to a URI yields an equivalent
URI.
Note that CRIs are defined to enable implementing conversions from
or to URIs analogously to processing URIs into CoAP Options and
back, with the exception that item 8 of Section 6.4 of [RFC7252]
and item 7 of Section 6.5 of [RFC7252] do not apply to CRI
processing. See SP1 in Appendix B for more details.
CRI to IRI
A CRI can be converted to an IRI by first converting it to a URI
as specified in Section 6.1, and then converting the URI to an IRI
as described in Section 3.2 of [RFC3987].
IRI to CRI
An IRI can be converted to a CRI by first converting it to a URI
as described in Section 3.1 of [RFC3987], and then converting the
URI to a CRI as described above.
Everything in this section also applies to CRI references, URI
references and IRI references.
6.1. Converting CRIs to URIs
Applications MUST convert a CRI reference to a URI reference by
determining the components of the URI reference according to the
following steps and then recomposing the components to a URI
reference string as specified in Section 5.3 of [RFC3986].
Bormann & Birkholz Expires 11 January 2024 [Page 17]
Internet-Draft Constrained Resource Identifiers July 2023
scheme
If the CRI reference contains a scheme section, the scheme
component of the URI reference consists of the value of that
section, if text (scheme-name); or, if a negative integer is given
(scheme-id), the lower case scheme name corresponding to the
scheme number as per the CRI Scheme Numbers registry Section 10.1.
Otherwise, the scheme component is unset.
authority
If the CRI reference contains a host-name or host-ip item, the
authority component of the URI reference consists of a host
subcomponent, optionally followed by a colon (":") character and a
port subcomponent, optionally preceded by a userinfo subcomponent.
Otherwise, the authority component is unset.
The host subcomponent consists of the value of the host-name or
host-ip item.
The userinfo subcomponent, if present, is turned into a single
string by appending a "@". Otherwise, both the subcomponent and
the "@" sign are omitted. Any character in the value of the
userinfo elements that is not in the set of unreserved characters
(Section 2.3 of [RFC3986]) or "sub-delims" (Section 2.2 of
[RFC3986]) MUST be percent-encoded.
The host-name is turned into a single string by joining the
elements separated by dots ("."). Any character in the elements
of a host-name item that is not in the set of unreserved
characters (Section 2.3 of [RFC3986]) or "sub-delims" (Section 2.2
of [RFC3986]) MUST be percent-encoded. If there are dots (".") in
such elements, the conversion fails (percent-encoding is not able
to represent such elements, as normalization would turn the
percent-encoding back to the unreserved character that a dot is.)
The value of a host-ip item MUST be represented as a string that
matches the "IPv4address" or "IP-literal" rule (Section 3.2.2 of
[RFC3986]). Any zone-id is appended to the string, separated by
"%25" as defined in Section 2 of [RFC6874], or as specified in a
superseding zone-id specification document
[I-D.carpenter-6man-rfc6874bis]; this also leads to a modified
"IP-literal" rule as specified in these documents.
If the CRI reference contains a port item, the port subcomponent
consists of the value of that item in decimal notation.
Otherwise, the colon (":") character and the port subcomponent are
both omitted.
path
Bormann & Birkholz Expires 11 January 2024 [Page 18]
Internet-Draft Constrained Resource Identifiers July 2023
If the CRI reference contains a discard item of value true, the
path component is considered _rooted_. If it contains a discard
item of value 0 and the path item is present, the conversion
fails. If it contains a positive discard item, the path component
is considered _unrooted_ and prefixed by as many "../" components
as the discard value minus one indicates. If the discard value is
1 and the first element of the path contains a :, the path
component is prefixed by "./" (this avoids the first element to
appear as supplying a URI scheme; compare path-noscheme in
Section 4.2 of [RFC3986]).
If the discard item is not present and the CRI reference contains
an authority that is true, the path component of the URI reference
is considered unrooted. Otherwise, the path component is
considered rooted.
If the CRI reference contains one or more path items, the path
component is constructed by concatenating the sequence of
representations of these items. These representations generally
contain a leading slash ("/") character and the value of each
item, processed as discussed below. The leading slash character
is omitted for the first path item only if the path component is
considered "unrooted".
Any character in the value of a path item that is not in the set
of unreserved characters or "sub-delims" or a colon (":") or
commercial at ("@") character MUST be percent-encoded.
If the authority component is present (not null or true) and the
path component does not match the "path-abempty" rule (Section 3.3
of [RFC3986]), the conversion fails.
If the authority component is not present, but the scheme
component is, and the path component does not match the "path-
absolute", "path-rootless" (authority == true) or "path-empty"
rule (Section 3.3 of [RFC3986]), the conversion fails.
If neither the authority component nor the scheme component are
present, and the path component does not match the "path-
absolute", "path-noscheme" or "path-empty" rule (Section 3.3 of
[RFC3986]), the conversion fails.
query
If the CRI reference contains one or more query items, the query
component of the URI reference consists of the value of each item,
separated by an ampersand ("&") character. Otherwise, the query
component is unset.
Bormann & Birkholz Expires 11 January 2024 [Page 19]
Internet-Draft Constrained Resource Identifiers July 2023
Any character in the value of a query item that is not in the set
of unreserved characters or "sub-delims" or a colon (":"),
commercial at ("@"), slash ("/") or question mark ("?") character
MUST be percent-encoded. Additionally, any ampersand character
("&") in the item value MUST be percent-encoded.
fragment
If the CRI reference contains a fragment item, the fragment
component of the URI reference consists of the value of that item.
Otherwise, the fragment component is unset.
Any character in the value of a fragment item that is not in the
set of unreserved characters or "sub-delims" or a colon (":"),
commercial at ("@"), slash ("/") or question mark ("?") character
MUST be percent-encoded.
7. Extending CRIs
CRIs have been designed to relieve implementations operating on CRIs
from string scanning, which both helps constrained implementations
and implementations that need to achieve high throughput.
The CRI structure described up to this point is termed the _Basic
CRI_. It should be sufficient for all applications that use the CoAP
protocol, as well as most other protocols employing URIs.
However, Basic CRIs have one limitation: They do not support URI
components that _require_ percent-encoding (Section 2.1 of [RFC3986])
to represent them in the URI syntax, except where that percent-
encoding is used to escape the main delimiter in use.
E.g., the URI
https://alice/3%2f4-inch
is represented by the basic CRI
[-4, ["alice"], ["3/4-inch"]]
However, percent-encoding that is used at the application level is
not supported by basic CRIs:
did:web:alice:7%3A1-balun
Extended forms of CRIs may be defined to enable these applications.
They will generally extend the potential values of text components of
URIs, such as userinfo, hostnames, paths, queries, and fragments.
Bormann & Birkholz Expires 11 January 2024 [Page 20]
Internet-Draft Constrained Resource Identifiers July 2023
One such extended form is described in the following Section 7.1.
Consumers of CRIs will generally notice when an extended form is in
use, by finding structures that do not match the CDDL rules given in
Figure 1. Future definitions of extended forms need to strive to be
distinguishable in their structures from the extended form presented
here as well as other future forms.
Extensions to CRIs MUST NOT allow indefinite length items. This
provision ensures that recipients o CRIs can deal with unprocessable
CRIs as described in Section 5.2.1.
7.1. Extended CRI: Accommodating Percent Encoding (PET)
This section presents a method to represent percent-encoded segments
of userinfo, hostnames, paths, and queries, as well as fragments.
The four CDDL rules
userinfo = (false, text .feature "userinfo")
host-name = (*text)
path = [*text]
query = [+text]
fragment = text
are replaced with
userinfo = (false, text-or-pet .feature "userinfo")
host-name = (*text-or-pet)
path = [*text-or-pet]
query = [+text-or-pet]
fragment = text-or-pet
text-or-pet = text /
text-pet-sequence .feature "extended-cri"
; text1 and pet1 alternating, at least one pet1:
text-pet-sequence = [?text1, ((+(pet1, text1), ?pet1) // pet1)]
; pet is percent-encoded bytes
pet1 = bytes .ne ''
text1 = text .ne ""
That is, for each of the host-name, path, and query segments, and for
the userinfo and fragment components, an alternate representation is
provided besides a simple text string: a non-empty array of
alternating non-blank text and byte strings, the text strings of
which stand for non-percent-encoded text, while the byte strings
retain the special semantics of percent-encoded text without actually
being percent-encoded.
Bormann & Birkholz Expires 11 January 2024 [Page 21]
Internet-Draft Constrained Resource Identifiers July 2023
The above DID URI can now be represented as:
[-6, true, [["web:alice:7", ':', "1-balun"]]]
(Note that, in CBOR diagnostic notation, single quotes delimit
literals for byte strings, double quotes for text strings.)
To yield a valid extended-cri, the use of byte strings MUST be
minimal. Both the following examples are therefore not valid:
[-6, true, [["web:alice:", '7:', "1-balun"]]]
[-6, true, [["web:alice:7", ':1', "-balun"]]]
An algorithm for constructing a valid text-pet-sequence might
repeatedly examine the byte sequences in each byte string; if such a
sequence stands for an unreserved ASCII character, or constitutes a
valid UTF-8 character ≥ U+0080, move this character over into a text
string by appending it to the end of the preceding text string,
prepending it to the start of the following text string, or splitting
the byte string and inserting a new text string with this character,
all while preserving the order of the bytes. (Note that the
properties of UTF-8 make this a simple linear process.)
| Unlike the text elements of a path or a query, which through
| CoAP's heritage are designed to be processable element by
| element, a text-pet-sequence does not usually produce a
| semantically meaningful division into array elements. This
| consequence of the flexibility in delimiters offered in URIs is
| demonstrated by this example, which structurally singles out
| the one ':' that is _not_ a delimiter at the application level.
| Applications designed for using CRIs will generally avoid using
| the extended-cri feature. Applications using existing URI
| structures that require text-pet-sequence elements for their
| representation typically need to process them byte by byte.
8. Implementation Status
With the exception of the authority=true fix, host-names split into
labels, and Section 7.1, CRIs are implemented in
https://gitlab.com/chrysn/micrurus. A golang implementation of
version -10 of this document is found at: https://github.com/thomas-
fossati/href
Bormann & Birkholz Expires 11 January 2024 [Page 22]
Internet-Draft Constrained Resource Identifiers July 2023
9. Security Considerations
Parsers of CRI references must operate on input that is assumed to be
untrusted. This means that parsers MUST fail gracefully in the face
of malicious inputs. Additionally, parsers MUST be prepared to deal
with resource exhaustion (e.g., resulting from the allocation of big
data items) or exhaustion of the call stack (stack overflow). See
Section 10 of [RFC8949] for additional security considerations
relating to CBOR.
The security considerations discussed in Section 7 of [RFC3986] and
Section 8 of [RFC3987] for URIs and IRIs also apply to CRIs.
10. IANA Considerations
10.1. CRI Scheme Numbers Registry
This specification defines a new "CRI Scheme Numbers" sub-registry in
the "CoRE Parameters" registry [IANA.core-parameters], with the
policy "Expert Review" (Section 4.5 of [BCP26]). The objective is to
have CRI scheme number values registered for all registered URI
schemes (Uniform Resource Identifier (URI) Schemes registry), as well
as exceptionally for certain text strings that the Designated Expert
considers widely used in constrained applications in place of URI
scheme names.
10.1.1. Instructions for the Designated Expert
The expert is instructed to be frugal in the allocation of CRI values
with short representations (1+0 and 1+1 encoding), keeping them in
reserve for applications that are likely to enjoy wide use and can
make good use of their shortness.
When the expert notices that a registration has been made in the
Uniform Resource Identifier (URI) Schemes registry (see also
Section 10.2), the expert is requested to initiate a parallel
registration in the CRI Scheme Numbers registry. CRI values in the
range between 1000 and 20000 (inclusive) should be assigned unless a
shorter representation in CRIs appears desirable.
The expert exceptionally also may make such a registration for text
strings that have not been registered in the Uniform Resource
Identifier (URI) Schemes registry if and only if the expert considers
the to be in wide use in place of URI scheme names in constrained
applications. (Note that the initial registrations in Table 1
already include such registrations for the text strings "mqtt" and
"mqtts".)
Bormann & Birkholz Expires 11 January 2024 [Page 23]
Internet-Draft Constrained Resource Identifiers July 2023
A registration in the CRI Scheme Numbers registry does not imply that
a URI scheme under this name exists or has been registered in the
Uniform Resource Identifier (URI) Schemes registry -- it essentially
is only providing an integer identifier for an otherwise
uninterpreted text string.
Any questions or issues that might interest a wider audience might be
raised by the expert on the core-parameters@ietf.org mailing list for
a time-limited discussion.
10.1.2. Structure of Entries
Each entry in the registry must include:
CRI value:
A negative integer unique in this registry
URI scheme name:
a text string that would be acceptable for registration as a URI
Scheme Name in the Uniform Resource Identifier (URI) Schemes
registry
Reference:
a reference to a document, if available, or the registrant
10.1.3. Initial Registrations
The initial registrations for the CRI Scheme Numbers registry are
provided in Table 1.
10.2. Update to "Uniform Resource Identifier (URI) Schemes" Registry
[RFC7595] is updated to add the following note in the "Uniform
Resource Identifier (URI) Schemes" Registry [IANA.uri-schemes]:
| The CRI Scheme Numbers Registry registers numeric identifiers for
| what essentially are URI Scheme names. Registrants for the
| Uniform Resource Identifier (URI) Schemes Registry are requested
| to make a parallel registration in the CRI Scheme Numbers
| registry. The number for this registration will be assigned by
| the Designated Expert for that registry.
11. References
11.1. Normative References
Bormann & Birkholz Expires 11 January 2024 [Page 24]
Internet-Draft Constrained Resource Identifiers July 2023
[BCP26] Cotton, M., Leiba, B., and T. Narten, "Guidelines for
Writing an IANA Considerations Section in RFCs", BCP 26,
RFC 8126, DOI 10.17487/RFC8126, June 2017,
<https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc8126>.
[I-D.carpenter-6man-rfc6874bis]
Carpenter, B. E., Cheshire, S., and R. M. Hinden,
"Representing IPv6 Zone Identifiers in Address Literals
and Uniform Resource Identifiers", Work in Progress,
Internet-Draft, draft-carpenter-6man-rfc6874bis-03, 8
February 2022, <https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/html/
draft-carpenter-6man-rfc6874bis-03>.
[IANA.core-parameters]
IANA, "Constrained RESTful Environments (CoRE)
Parameters",
<https://www.iana.org/assignments/core-parameters>.
[IANA.uri-schemes]
IANA, "Uniform Resource Identifier (URI) Schemes",
<https://www.iana.org/assignments/uri-schemes>.
[RFC2119] Bradner, S., "Key words for use in RFCs to Indicate
Requirement Levels", BCP 14, RFC 2119,
DOI 10.17487/RFC2119, March 1997,
<https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc2119>.
[RFC3986] Berners-Lee, T., Fielding, R., and L. Masinter, "Uniform
Resource Identifier (URI): Generic Syntax", STD 66,
RFC 3986, DOI 10.17487/RFC3986, January 2005,
<https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc3986>.
[RFC3987] Duerst, M. and M. Suignard, "Internationalized Resource
Identifiers (IRIs)", RFC 3987, DOI 10.17487/RFC3987,
January 2005, <https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc3987>.
[RFC6874] Carpenter, B., Cheshire, S., and R. Hinden, "Representing
IPv6 Zone Identifiers in Address Literals and Uniform
Resource Identifiers", RFC 6874, DOI 10.17487/RFC6874,
February 2013, <https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc6874>.
[RFC7595] Thaler, D., Ed., Hansen, T., and T. Hardie, "Guidelines
and Registration Procedures for URI Schemes", BCP 35,
RFC 7595, DOI 10.17487/RFC7595, June 2015,
<https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc7595>.
Bormann & Birkholz Expires 11 January 2024 [Page 25]
Internet-Draft Constrained Resource Identifiers July 2023
[RFC8174] Leiba, B., "Ambiguity of Uppercase vs Lowercase in RFC
2119 Key Words", BCP 14, RFC 8174, DOI 10.17487/RFC8174,
May 2017, <https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc8174>.
[RFC8610] Birkholz, H., Vigano, C., and C. Bormann, "Concise Data
Definition Language (CDDL): A Notational Convention to
Express Concise Binary Object Representation (CBOR) and
JSON Data Structures", RFC 8610, DOI 10.17487/RFC8610,
June 2019, <https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc8610>.
[RFC8949] Bormann, C. and P. Hoffman, "Concise Binary Object
Representation (CBOR)", STD 94, RFC 8949,
DOI 10.17487/RFC8949, December 2020,
<https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc8949>.
[RFC9165] Bormann, C., "Additional Control Operators for the Concise
Data Definition Language (CDDL)", RFC 9165,
DOI 10.17487/RFC9165, December 2021,
<https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc9165>.
[Unicode] The Unicode Consortium, "The Unicode Standard, Version
13.0.0", ISBN 978-1-936213-26-9, March 2020,
<https://www.unicode.org/versions/Unicode13.0.0/>.
11.2. Informative References
[RFC4180] Shafranovich, Y., "Common Format and MIME Type for Comma-
Separated Values (CSV) Files", RFC 4180,
DOI 10.17487/RFC4180, October 2005,
<https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc4180>.
[RFC7228] Bormann, C., Ersue, M., and A. Keranen, "Terminology for
Constrained-Node Networks", RFC 7228,
DOI 10.17487/RFC7228, May 2014,
<https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc7228>.
[RFC7252] Shelby, Z., Hartke, K., and C. Bormann, "The Constrained
Application Protocol (CoAP)", RFC 7252,
DOI 10.17487/RFC7252, June 2014,
<https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc7252>.
[RFC8141] Saint-Andre, P. and J. Klensin, "Uniform Resource Names
(URNs)", RFC 8141, DOI 10.17487/RFC8141, April 2017,
<https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc8141>.
[RFC8288] Nottingham, M., "Web Linking", RFC 8288,
DOI 10.17487/RFC8288, October 2017,
<https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc8288>.
Bormann & Birkholz Expires 11 January 2024 [Page 26]
Internet-Draft Constrained Resource Identifiers July 2023
[RFC8820] Nottingham, M., "URI Design and Ownership", BCP 190,
RFC 8820, DOI 10.17487/RFC8820, June 2020,
<https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc8820>.
[RFC9110] Fielding, R., Ed., Nottingham, M., Ed., and J. Reschke,
Ed., "HTTP Semantics", STD 97, RFC 9110,
DOI 10.17487/RFC9110, June 2022,
<https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc9110>.
[W3C.REC-html52-20171214]
Danilo, A., Ed., Eicholz, A., Ed., Moon, S., Ed.,
Faulkner, S., Ed., and T. Leithead, Ed., "HTML 5.2", W3C
REC REC-html52-20171214, W3C REC-html52-20171214, 14
December 2017,
<https://www.w3.org/TR/2017/REC-html52-20171214/>.
Appendix A. Mapping Scheme Numbers to Scheme Names
Table 1 defines the initial mapping from CRI scheme numbers to URI
scheme names.
+===========+======================================+===========+
| CRI value | URI scheme | Reference |
+===========+======================================+===========+
| -1 | coap | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -2 | coaps | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -3 | http | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -4 | https | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -5 | urn | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -6 | did | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -7 | coap+tcp | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -8 | coaps+tcp | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -9 | coap+ws | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -10 | coaps+ws | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -1025 | telnet | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -1046 | ldap | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
Bormann & Birkholz Expires 11 January 2024 [Page 27]
Internet-Draft Constrained Resource Identifiers July 2023
| -1056 | ms-virtualtouchpad | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -1091 | fax | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -1107 | ves | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -1147 | submit | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -1192 | gg | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -1219 | simplex | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -1240 | ms-settings-nfctransactions | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -1241 | secret-token | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -1249 | acap | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -1276 | openpgp4fpr | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -1300 | ms-mixedrealitycapture | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -1307 | ymsgr | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -1320 | iris.xpcs | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -1351 | turns | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -1367 | opaquelocktoken | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -1499 | platform | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -1597 | sftp | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -1613 | vscode | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -1649 | mqtt | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -1664 | ms-settings | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -1690 | doi | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -1720 | file | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -1729 | dvb | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -1760 | magnet | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
Bormann & Birkholz Expires 11 January 2024 [Page 28]
Internet-Draft Constrained Resource Identifiers July 2023
| -1768 | calculator | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -1836 | ssh | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -1966 | gopher | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -1985 | ms-gamingoverlay | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -1997 | z39.50 | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -2032 | ms-secondary-screen-setup | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -2038 | fido | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -2085 | mumble | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -2095 | ms-settings-cloudstorage | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -2106 | imap | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -2152 | ms-officeapp | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -2233 | pwid | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -2236 | drm | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -2264 | tag | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -2369 | feed | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -2460 | ipps | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -2484 | xmlrpc.beeps | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -2492 | jms | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -2542 | wpid | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -2669 | barion | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -2675 | onenote | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -2695 | icon | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -2769 | message | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -2800 | ms-enrollment | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
Bormann & Birkholz Expires 11 January 2024 [Page 29]
Internet-Draft Constrained Resource Identifiers July 2023
| -2804 | bolo | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -2817 | diaspora | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -2833 | microsoft.windows.camera.picker | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -2864 | notes | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -2866 | amss | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -2873 | tip | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -3018 | fm | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -3042 | rtmfp | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -3060 | reload | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -3111 | pres | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -3232 | acd | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -3362 | prospero | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -3364 | geo | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -3414 | snmp | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -3483 | iris.beep | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -3510 | maps | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -3575 | content | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -3618 | pack | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -3619 | keyparc | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -3632 | mongodb | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -3693 | smb | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -3796 | graph | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -3818 | filesystem | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -3839 | payment | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
Bormann & Birkholz Expires 11 January 2024 [Page 30]
Internet-Draft Constrained Resource Identifiers July 2023
| -3840 | ms-settings-bluetooth | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -3951 | palm | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -4027 | hyper | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -4043 | microsoft.windows.camera | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -4067 | mvn | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -4098 | mtqp | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -4130 | jabber | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -4275 | mms | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -4343 | skype | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -4351 | oid | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -4420 | dict | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -4454 | attachment | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -4662 | ocf | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -4807 | isostore | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -4816 | redis | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -4862 | ms-settings-privacy | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -4877 | ms-settings-wifi | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -5004 | v-event | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -5020 | com-eventbrite-attendee | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -5105 | teliaeid | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -5222 | itms | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -5234 | fish | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -5285 | dtn | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -5298 | vscode-insiders | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
Bormann & Birkholz Expires 11 January 2024 [Page 31]
Internet-Draft Constrained Resource Identifiers July 2023
| -5304 | tftp | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -5347 | rtsp | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -5358 | adiumxtra | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -5464 | smp | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -5470 | ms-eyecontrolspeech | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -5479 | ms-settings-language | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -5491 | mqtts | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -5595 | wyciwyg | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -5596 | hcp | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -5619 | go | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -5673 | rediss | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -5683 | ms-settings-cellular | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -5743 | ldaps | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -5843 | z39.50s | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -5886 | bitcoincash | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -5960 | ms-mobileplans | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -6182 | pttp | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -6208 | facetime | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -6289 | gtalk | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -6348 | afp | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -6361 | mss | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -6426 | ms-settings-notifications | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -6448 | psyc | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -6488 | tv | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
Bormann & Birkholz Expires 11 January 2024 [Page 32]
Internet-Draft Constrained Resource Identifiers July 2023
| -6514 | wifi | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -6523 | sarif | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -6539 | moz | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -6659 | ms-lockscreencomponent-config | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -6716 | cabal | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -6734 | ms-media-stream-id | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -6780 | mupdate | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -6793 | dis | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -6804 | nih | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -6809 | ms-help | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -6909 | soap.beep | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -6998 | iotdisco | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -7027 | acr | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -7040 | ms-newsandinterests | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -7089 | hxxp | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -7096 | ms-settings-location | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -7125 | soap.beeps | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -7301 | ipn | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -7309 | nntp | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -7316 | query | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -7334 | smtp | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -7335 | ms-spd | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -7400 | ni | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -7403 | ms-excel | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
Bormann & Birkholz Expires 11 January 2024 [Page 33]
Internet-Draft Constrained Resource Identifiers July 2023
| -7421 | ms-settings-power | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -7435 | pop | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -7447 | session | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -7582 | ms-infopath | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -7701 | ms-word | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -7715 | web+ap | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -7791 | steam | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -7995 | cstr | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -8008 | web3 | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -8064 | videotex | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -8069 | nfs | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -8094 | udp | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -8102 | ed2k | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -8138 | ms-getoffice | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -8203 | sgn | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -8331 | data | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -8364 | swidpath | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -8385 | fuchsia-pkg | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -8395 | ms-screensketch | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -8426 | hxxps | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -8487 | unreal | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -8555 | ens | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -8585 | ms-settings-camera | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -8619 | stun | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
Bormann & Birkholz Expires 11 January 2024 [Page 34]
Internet-Draft Constrained Resource Identifiers July 2023
| -8673 | ms-stickers | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -8775 | spotify | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -8860 | starknet | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -8890 | ms-settings-emailandaccounts | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -8907 | market | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -8967 | ms-powerpoint | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -9001 | rtsps | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -9064 | p1 | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -9128 | aw | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -9132 | mailserver | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -9186 | irc6 | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -9338 | ms-settings-lock | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -9339 | hcap | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -9350 | drop | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -9419 | icap | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -9437 | xcon-userid | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -9457 | leaptofrogans | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -9461 | ipfs | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -9479 | bitcoin | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -9555 | apt | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -9605 | ms-whiteboard-cmd | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -9669 | ssb | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -9725 | aaas | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -9734 | ar | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
Bormann & Birkholz Expires 11 January 2024 [Page 35]
Internet-Draft Constrained Resource Identifiers July 2023
| -9767 | proxy | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -9773 | res | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -9780 | msrps | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -9795 | aim | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -9826 | tool | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -9842 | finger | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -9900 | turn | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -9901 | num | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -9903 | svn | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -9904 | ut2004 | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -9932 | ms-visio | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -10008 | eid | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -10100 | wss | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -10103 | gizmoproject | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -10172 | dlna-playsingle | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -10224 | swh | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -10337 | dat | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -10348 | cap | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -10355 | z39.50r | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -10412 | xcon | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -10430 | gitoid | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -10524 | hydrazone | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -10565 | example | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -10699 | crid | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
Bormann & Birkholz Expires 11 January 2024 [Page 36]
Internet-Draft Constrained Resource Identifiers July 2023
| -10717 | teamspeak | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -10743 | elsi | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -10769 | dtmi | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -10840 | ftp | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -10902 | ms-drive-to | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -10903 | upt | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -10911 | appdata | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -11039 | callto | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -11131 | ms-remotedesktop-launch | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -11139 | dweb | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -11264 | lastfm | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -11307 | xmlrpc.beep | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -11342 | ms-whiteboard | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -11465 | first-run-pen-experience | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -11473 | webcal | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -11553 | adt | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -11566 | vemmi | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -11590 | cvs | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -11629 | taler | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -11688 | ms-inputapp | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -11864 | git | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -11893 | irc | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -11936 | ms-settings-workplace | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -12171 | blob | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
Bormann & Birkholz Expires 11 January 2024 [Page 37]
Internet-Draft Constrained Resource Identifiers July 2023
| -12173 | modem | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -12188 | msnim | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -12268 | iris.lwz | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -12302 | ms-sttoverlay | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -12321 | lbry | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -12334 | rmi | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -12346 | ms-restoretabcompanion | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -12482 | ms-useractivityset | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -12485 | dab | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -12491 | about | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -12500 | embedded | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -12501 | rtmp | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -12526 | ircs | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -12558 | mid | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -12573 | sip | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -12593 | ipns | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -12666 | dvx | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -12706 | android | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -12747 | wtai | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -12831 | ms-search-repair | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -12838 | microsoft.windows.camera.multipicker | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -12857 | ms-settings-screenrotation | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -12879 | rtspu | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -12914 | ms-screenclip | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
Bormann & Birkholz Expires 11 January 2024 [Page 38]
Internet-Draft Constrained Resource Identifiers July 2023
| -12943 | aaa | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -12954 | xmpp | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -12988 | soldat | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -13041 | lorawan | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -13054 | beshare | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -13077 | sips | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -13081 | iris.xpc | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -13113 | simpleledger | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -13127 | vsls | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -13207 | matrix | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -13307 | otpauth | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -13336 | cid | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -13352 | service | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -13417 | h323 | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -13438 | ms-settings-connectabledevices | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -13452 | payto | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -13463 | ms-settings-displays-topology | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -13505 | lvlt | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -13596 | ms-walk-to | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -13672 | dns | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -13730 | quic-transport | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -13762 | paparazzi | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -13766 | ms-people | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -13889 | xri | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
Bormann & Birkholz Expires 11 January 2024 [Page 39]
Internet-Draft Constrained Resource Identifiers July 2023
| -13894 | onenote-cmd | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -13934 | dav | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -14003 | content-type | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -14068 | sms | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -14119 | ms-publisher | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -14197 | xfire | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -14250 | secondlife | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -14260 | ark | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -14301 | iax | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -14312 | msrp | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -14475 | swid | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -14590 | tn3270 | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -14596 | ms-appinstaller | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -14627 | stuns | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -14688 | dpp | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -14701 | ms-secondary-screen-controller | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -14764 | browserext | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -14820 | chrome | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -14878 | pkcs11 | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -15066 | dlna-playcontainer | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -15155 | spiffe | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -15207 | uuid-in-package | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -15261 | ms-settings-proximity | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -15356 | things | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
Bormann & Birkholz Expires 11 January 2024 [Page 40]
Internet-Draft Constrained Resource Identifiers July 2023
| -15377 | ms-gamebarservices | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -15379 | shc | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -15547 | ipp | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -15552 | mailto | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -15558 | ms-browser-extension | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -15838 | shttp (OBSOLETE) | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -15842 | acct | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -15849 | w3 | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -15869 | wais | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -15928 | qb | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -15947 | ms-search | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -16043 | ms-settings-airplanemode | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -16045 | jar | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -16069 | tel | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -16074 | dntp | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -16160 | chrome-extension | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -16193 | cast | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -16326 | view-source | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -16356 | im | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -16358 | resource | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -16378 | ms-calculator | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -16380 | news | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -16415 | wcr | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -16523 | casts | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
Bormann & Birkholz Expires 11 January 2024 [Page 41]
Internet-Draft Constrained Resource Identifiers July 2023
| -16689 | ms-access | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -16723 | grd | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -16750 | rsync | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -16773 | lpa | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -16850 | afs | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -16874 | bb | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -16884 | ham | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -16926 | info | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -16972 | ms-meetnow | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -17117 | ms-project | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -17172 | ethereum | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -17225 | thismessage | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -17226 | vnc | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -17232 | snews | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -17245 | sieve | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -17269 | feedready | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -17271 | mt | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -17288 | ws | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -17338 | ms-transit-to | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -17346 | ventrilo | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
| -17357 | iris | [RFCthis] |
+-----------+--------------------------------------+-----------+
Table 1: Mapping Scheme Numbers to Scheme Names
The assignments from this table can be extracted from the XML form of
this document (when stored in a file "this.xml") into CSV form
[RFC4180] using this short Ruby program:
Bormann & Birkholz Expires 11 January 2024 [Page 42]
Internet-Draft Constrained Resource Identifiers July 2023
require 'rexml/document'; include REXML
XPath.each(Document.new(File.read("this.xml")),"//tr") {|row|
puts XPath.each(row,"td").map{|d|d.text()}[0..1].join(",")}
Appendix B. The Small Print
This appendix lists a few corner cases of URI semantics that
implementers of CRIs need to be aware of, but that are not
representative of the normal operation of CRIs.
SP1. Initial (Lone/Leading) Empty Path Segments:
* _Lone empty path segments:_ As per [RFC3986], s://x is distinct
from s://x/ -- i.e., a URI with an empty path ([] in CRI) is
different from one with a lone empty path segment ([""]).
However, in HTTP and CoAP, they are implicitly aliased (for CoAP,
in item 8 of Section 6.4 of [RFC7252]). As per item 7 of
Section 6.5 of [RFC7252], recomposition of a URI without Uri-Path
Options from the other URI-related CoAP Options produces s://x/,
not s://x -- CoAP prefers the lone empty path segment form.
Similarly, after discussing HTTP semantics, Section 6.2.3 of
[RFC3986] states:
| In general, a URI that uses the generic syntax for authority with
| an empty path should be normalized to a path of "/".
* _Leading empty path segments without authority_: Somewhat related,
note also that URIs and URI references that do not carry an
authority cannot represent initial empty path segments (i.e., that
are followed by further path segments): s://x//foo works, but in a
s://foo URI or an (absolute-path) URI reference of the form //foo
the double slash would be mis-parsed as leading in to an
authority.
SP2. Constraints (Section 2) of CRIs/basic CRIs
While most URIs in everyday use can be converted to CRIs and
back to URIs matching the input after syntax-based
normalization of the URI, these URIs illustrate the constraints
by example:
* https://host%ffname, https://example.com/x?data=%ff
All URI components must, after percent decoding, be valid
UTF-8 encoded text. Bytes that are not valid UTF-8 show up,
for example, in BitTorrent web seeds.
Bormann & Birkholz Expires 11 January 2024 [Page 43]
Internet-Draft Constrained Resource Identifiers July 2023
* https://example.com/component%3bone;component%3btwo,
http://example.com/component%3dequals
While delimiters can be used in an escaped and unescaped
form in URIs with generally distinct meanings, basic CRIs
(i.e., without percent-encoded text Section 7.1) only
support one escapable delimiter character per component,
which is the delimiter by which the component is split up in
the CRI.
Note that the separators . (for authority parts), / (for
paths), & (for query parameters) are special in that they
are syntactic delimiters of their respective components in
CRIs. Thus, the following examples _are_ convertible to
basic CRIs:
https://interior%2edot/
https://example.com/path%2fcomponent/second-component
https://example.com/x?ampersand=%26&questionmark=?
* https://alice@example.com/
The user information can be expressed in CRIs if the
"userinfo" feature is present. The URI https://@example.com
is represented as [-4, [false, "", "example", "com"]]; the
false serves as a marker that the next element is the
userinfo.
The rules do not cater for unencoded ":" in userinfo, which
is commonly considered a deprecated inclusion of a literal
password.
Appendix C. Change Log
This section is to be removed before publishing as an RFC.
Changes from -08 to -09
* Identify more esoteric features with a CDDL ".feature".
* Clarify that well-formedness requires removing trailing nulls.
* Fragments can contain PET.
* Percent-encoded text in PET is treated as byte strings.
Bormann & Birkholz Expires 11 January 2024 [Page 44]
Internet-Draft Constrained Resource Identifiers July 2023
* URIs with an authority but a completely empty path (e.g.,
http://example.com): CRIs with an authority component no longer
always produce at least a slash in the path component.
For generic schemes, the conversion of scheme://example.com to a
CRI is now possible because CRI produces a URI with an authority
not followed by a slash following the updated rules of
Section 6.1. Schemes like http and coap do not distinguish
between the empty path and the path containing a single slash when
an authority is set (as recommended in [RFC3986]). For these
schemes, that equivalence allows implementations to convert the
just-a-slash URI to a CRI with a zero length path array (which,
however, when converted back, does not produce a slash after the
authority).
(Add an appendix "the small print" for more detailed discussion of
pesky corner cases like this.)
Changes from -07 to -08
* Fix the encoding of NOAUTH-NOSLASH / NOAUTH-LEADINGSLASH
* Add URN and DID schemes, add example.
* Add PET
* Remove hopeless attempt to encode "remote trailing nulls" rule in
CDDL (which is not a transformation language).
Changes from -06 to -07
* More explicitly discuss constraints (Section 2), add examples
(Appendix B, Paragraph 6, Item 1).
* Make CDDL more explicit about special simple values.
* Lots of gratuitous changes from XML2RFC redefinition of <tt>
semantics.
Changes from -05 to -06
* rework authority:
- split reg-names at dots;
- add optional zone identifiers [RFC6874] to IP addresses
Changes from -04 to -05
Bormann & Birkholz Expires 11 January 2024 [Page 45]
Internet-Draft Constrained Resource Identifiers July 2023
* Simplify CBOR structure.
* Add implementation status section.
Changes from -03 to -04:
* Minor editorial improvements.
* Renamed path.type/path-type to discard.
* Renamed option to section, substructured into items.
* Simplified the table "resolution-variables".
* Use the CBOR structure inspired by Jim Schaad's proposals.
Changes from -02 to -03:
* Expanded the set of supported schemes (#3).
* Specified creation, normalization and comparison (#9).
* Clarified the default value of the path.type option (#33).
* Removed the append-relation path.type option (#41).
* Renumbered the remaining path.types.
* Renumbered the option numbers.
* Restructured the document.
* Minor editorial improvements.
Changes from -01 to -02:
* Changed the syntax of schemes to exclude upper case characters
(#13).
* Minor editorial improvements (#34 #37).
Changes from -00 to -01:
* None.
Bormann & Birkholz Expires 11 January 2024 [Page 46]
Internet-Draft Constrained Resource Identifiers July 2023
Acknowledgements
CRIs were developed by Klaus Hartke for use in the Constrained
RESTful Application Language (CoRAL). The current author team is
completing this work with a view to achieve good integration with the
potential use cases, both inside and outside of CoRAL.
Thanks to Christian Amsüss, Thomas Fossati, Ari Keränen, Jim Schaad,
Dave Thaler and Marco Tiloca for helpful comments and discussions
that have shaped the document.
Contributors
Klaus Hartke
Ericsson
Torshamnsgatan 23
SE-16483 Stockholm
Sweden
Email: klaus.hartke@ericsson.com
Christian Amsüss
Hollandstr. 12/4
1020 Vienna
Austria
Email: christian@amsuess.com
Authors' Addresses
Carsten Bormann (editor)
Universität Bremen TZI
Postfach 330440
D-28359 Bremen
Germany
Phone: +49-421-218-63921
Email: cabo@tzi.org
Henk Birkholz
Fraunhofer SIT
Rheinstrasse 75
64295 Darmstadt
Germany
Email: henk.birkholz@sit.fraunhofer.de
Bormann & Birkholz Expires 11 January 2024 [Page 47]