(1) RFC is Standards Track, and this is the correct RFC type.
(2)
Technical Summary:
Due to a combination of unfortunate wording in earlier documents,
aggressive use of NSEC(3) records may deny names far beyond the
intended lifetime of a denial. This document changes the definition
of the NSEC(3) TTL to correct that situation. This document updates
RFC 4034, RFC 4035, and RFC 5155.
Working Group Summary:
Working group consensus was strong.
Document Quality:
While these are updates to existing standards, there is an implementation section where
open source software has implemented this.
Document Shepherd: Tim Wicinski
Responsible Area Director: Warren Kumari
(3) The Document Shepherd did a detailed review of the document
for content as well as simple editorial checks (spelling/grammar).
The shepherd feels the document is ready for publication.
(4) The Document Shepherd has no concerns on the depth or breadth
of the reviews.
(5) There is no need for broader review.
(6) There are no concerns from the document shepherd.
(7) No IPR disclosures
(8) There is no IPR
(9) The WG Consensus on this document is solid. There was one issue raised by Mr. StJohn on this
being a standards track document. We believe the author worked through these issues but we wanted
the IESG to be aware of this, and welcome any guidance on the issue:
https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/dnsop/bGJmfwLZQPBH7K72lQ8mOf3-s7k/
(10) There has been no appeals.
(11) All nits found have been addressed by the authors.
(12) No formal review needed
(13) All references have been identified as normative or informative.
(14) All normative references are in a clear state.
(15) There are no downward normative references
(16) This document will update RFCs 4034. 4035, and 5155, and they are in the abstract and the
introduction.
(17) The document shepherd confirmed the consistency and references of the
IANA Considerations section are accurate.
(18) There are no new IANA registries, only an update to the "Domain Name System
(DNS) Parameters" registry to reference this document.
(19) N/A
(20) No Yang Necessary