Current Open Questions in Path-Aware Networking
draft-irtf-panrg-questions-12
Yes
Colin Perkins
Jen Linkova
Laurent Ciavaglia
Spencer Dawkins
No Objection
Recuse
Brian Trammell
Note: This ballot was opened for revision 09 and is now closed.
Ballot question: "Is this draft ready for publication in the IRTF stream?"
Colin Perkins
Yes
Jen Linkova
Yes
Laurent Ciavaglia
Yes
Spencer Dawkins
Yes
Stephen Farrell
No Objection
Comment
(2021-07-26 for -09)
Sent
I had a quick read and it seems fine to me. I had expected to see some mention of the difficulty of meaningfully naming path elements or on-path routers - "Do you 'trust' a path using 2001:db8::bad, 2001:db8::dead and 2001:db8::f001 for openvpn.service?" not being soemthing lending itself to being answered with a human or random machine endpoint in the loop;-) Similarly, I wondered why longer term state information didn't give rise to any tricky questions - "Do you want to use the same path you used last week when you were physically in the office (now that you're back stuck doing WFH)?" But maybe the RG considered those questions already covered by some of those mentioned in the draft, which is ok.
Brian Trammell
Recuse