Forwarding and Control Element Separation

The information below is for an older proposed charter
Document Proposed charter Forwarding and Control Element Separation WG (forces) Snapshot
Title Forwarding and Control Element Separation
Last updated 2013-04-11
State Start Chartering/Rechartering (Internal Steering Group/IAB Review)
WG State Active
IESG Responsible AD Adrian Farrel
Charter Edit AD Adrian Farrel
Send notices to,


The ForCES working group has created a framework, requirements, a solution
protocol, a logical function block library, and other associated documents in
support of Forwarding and Control Element Separation.

The ForCES working group is now working on a set of additions to the model,
protocol, and libraries based on the experience gained from developing the
standards and from many efforts using this architecture.

The following 5 work items are the chartered tasks of this working group:

o Extensions to Model and Protocol

  This work is to address a set of extensions to the base model and protocol
  resulting in updates to RFCs 5810 and 5812. This effort will produce 2
  standards effort documents (one for the model and another for the protocol).

  The model extensions will:
  1. Allow complex metadata
  2. Allow optional default values for datatypes
  3. Allow optional access-type for datatypes inside complex components
  4. Define new base type: Bitmap
  5. Define new events to monitor states.

  The protocol extensions will:
  1. Support table range query
  2. Support table append
  3. Define additional return codes to reduce ambiguity
  4. Define data packing rule for bitmap datatype.

o Inter-FE Connectivity

  ForCES processing is often spread across multiple Forwarding Elements (FEs).
  The original framework identified the interface between FEs as the "Fi"
  reference point. Protocol and Logigal Function Block (LFB) mechanisms to
  carry metadata across the Fi interface are needed.  This effort will produce
  a standards track doument defining the protocol on the wire to address this
  need, and the LFBs used to represent the Interfaces for sending and receiving
  such information. It is expected that this work will draw heavily on existing
  protocol and LFB definitions.

o Paralellization

  An FE can implement an LFB chain with paralellization, but the currently-
  defined mechanism has no means to represent when synchronization is needed,
  or to allow the CE to specify where it believes such paralllism is useful.
  This work item will produce a single standards track document to improve the
  handling of this case.

o Subsidiary Management

  Deployment experience has demonstrated the value of using ForCES to control
  the Forwarding Element Manager (FEM) by creating an LFB to represent its
  function using the same encoding rules as for any other LFB. This allows it
  to be controlled by the same Control Element (CE). This work item assumes the
  presence of an initially booted FE whose configuration could then be updated
  at runtime via an FEM LFB for runtime config purposes (e.g., by adding a new
  CE and its associated IP address). This work item can also be useful in
  addressing control of virtual FEs where individual FEM Managers can be
  addressed to control the creation, configuration, and resource assignment of
  such virtual FEs within a physical FE. This work would result in a standards
  track LFB FEM library RFC.

In addition to the specific work items listed above, the working group will
allow discussions and review work of how to use ForCES to model topics of
interest to Network Function Virtualization, I2RS, or OpenFlow. It is
understood that the primary responsibility for such documents lives with other
working groups, individual contributions, or other standards bodies.

== Goals and Milestones ==
September 2013   Request for Publication of Standards Track document specifying
                 model changes
September 2013   Request for Publication of Standards Track document specifying
                 protocol changes
February 2014    Request for publication of Subsidiary management LFB
March 2014       Request for publication of Inter-FE LFB
March 2014       Request for publication of parallelization LFBs
April 2014       Recharter or shutdown